I like it for my 5th grader more than my 2nd grader.
These papers are great for the LO's I do for my son. This pack is very masculine, just wish that they included some paper that was slightly more femine so could have used them more in my daughters LO's. This package also does not include duplicates of the doubled paper. So If you plan to use front and back of the paper you are better off buying the indivdual sheets.
For my style, I found the patterns and colours a lot darker than I was expecting, and the plaids were very very bold, which made them impossible to use on anything that wasn't really focused on plaid (aka a page about Scotland, lol). So I haven't really enjoyed these papers as much as other Basic Grey collections, but if you're into plaid then it's right up your alley! The set is high quality and also does come with a lot of other neat patterns so it's still worth a buy!